What Are the Peppers That Come With Papa Johns?

Last Updated on June 29, 2023 by Lauren Beck

As someone who has relished countless Papa John’s pizzas, I’m familiar with the little treasure that arrives with each order—a container of peppers. 

In this tantalizing exploration, we’ll uncover these peppers’ identity, flavor profile, and how they elevate the pizza experience. Get ready to uncover the secrets behind Papa John’s zesty sidekick!

What Are the Peppers That Come With Papa Johns?

The peppers that come with Papa John’s pizza are pepperoncini peppers, which are mild to medium in spiciness, adding a tangy and slightly spicy kick to your pizza. 

These vibrant and flavorful peppers are popular among pizza lovers, providing a delightful contrast of flavors. 

So, when you order from Papa John’s, savor the delicious combination of their mouthwatering pizza and the zesty goodness of pepperoncini peppers.

Why Does Papa John’s Give You a Pepper?

  • Flavor Enhancement: The peppers provided by Papa John’s are not just an afterthought. They are carefully chosen to complement the flavors of their pizzas, adding a tangy and slightly spicy kick that elevates the taste experience.
  • Customer Preference: Many pizza lovers enjoy the combination of a zesty pepper alongside their slice. Papa John’s understands this preference and happily provides peppers to enhance their customers’ enjoyment.

Does Papa John’s Have Bell Peppers?

No, the peppers that come with Papa John’s pizza are not bell peppers. Instead, Papa John’s provides pepperoncini peppers and jalapeños to spice up your pizza experience.

How Spicy Is a Pepperoncini?

Pepperoncini Pepper on a Basket

Pepperoncini peppers have a mild to medium level of spiciness. They offer a pleasant heat that is generally well-tolerated by most people. 

While they provide a kick, it’s not overpowering, making them a popular choice for those who enjoy a milder spice profile.

How Do You Eat Papa John’s Pepperoncini?

  • Bite and Savor: The pepperoncini peppers are typically enjoyed by taking a bite directly from the stem. This allows you to savor the tangy and slightly spicy flavors of the pepper while enjoying your pizza.
  • Pairing Options: You can also slice the pepperoncini and add them as a topping to your pizza. They pair well with various pizza flavors, adding a delightful contrast of tanginess and heat.

What Jalapeños Does Papa John’s Use?

Papa John’s uses sliced jalapeños as an optional topping for their pizzas. 

These jalapeños offer a bolder heat than pepperoncini peppers [1], adding a spicier kick to your pizza if you’re seeking an extra fiery experience.


The peppers that come with Papa John’s pizza are none other than the vibrant and tangy pepperoncini peppers. These mild to medium spiced gems add a delightful kick to your pizza experience, perfectly complementing the flavors of the pie. Whether you enjoy them bite by bite or as a topping, the pepperoncini peppers enhance each slice with their unique tanginess. So, the next time you indulge in Papa John’s pizza, embrace the zesty goodness of these peppers and elevate your taste adventure to new heights. Let the tantalizing flavors of Papa John’s and pepperoncini peppers tantalize your palate.


Lauren Beck
Latest posts by Lauren Beck (see all)

Leave a Comment